Reviews

Jesse Michaelson

30 April 2024
24 days ago
I absolutely love going here for dessert. i love the amount of different self serve flavors they offer and ones that serve people with diet restrictions! They h...
Read more

Deanna Leviso

14 April 2024
a month ago
I’ve ordered from here before and not had issues but today I pulled a staple out my mouth after almost cutting my tongue. It was in a bite towards the bottom of...
Read more

Michael Pratt

10 March 2024
2 months ago
Good food, super friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable staff. Haley is amazing at kids parties. Will definitely come back again and again.

Shannon Mcguirk

05 March 2024
3 months ago
Great selection of toppings! I love the one price cup so I know exactly what I’m spending and everyone can get what they want!

Ronjo's Magic and Costumes

05 March 2024
3 months ago
This place is family friendly. It has great choices of ice cream and frozen yogurt and non-dairy products, plus they serve Acia Bowls always made fresh. A fun p...
Read more

June Williams

02 March 2024
3 months ago
Went in tonight with my 2 grandkids 5yr and 7yr. Had them grab the smaller white cups instead of the larger dotted cups so they didn't overfill with ice cream ...
Read more

Arianne

20 February 2024
3 months ago
Açaí bowl was so good and good price

David Pemberton

09 February 2024
3 months ago
Just wanted to give extra love as I see how hard the owner is trying to make this a wonderful place and I know how hard running a business can be.

Jacky Jan Ching

31 January 2024
4 months ago
Sundae Surprise: My nieces and nephews know our sweet tooth! Thanks to my adorable niece and nephew, I discovered a new dessert haven called Sundae, and let me...
Read more

Nysports Mcp

16 January 2024
4 months ago
Not bad but the Port Jeff Frigate is vastly superior. More of a selection of froyo flavors and better quality.

Shantell Estrada

12 January 2024
4 months ago
I have been ordering from here for a while Have yet to be let down 🫶🏽

Cheesy 45

10 October 2023
7 months ago
They had either vanilla or chocolate, those were pretty much the only flavors available. They had quite a few toppings, the only ones i found appealing had none...
Read more

Geoffrey Russell

02 September 2023
9 months ago
Ordered an egg cream and they gave me seltzer and milk in a cup, and when we went back to explain to them that an egg cream is seltzer, milk, and chocolate (or ...
Read more

Jackie Puzio

28 August 2023
9 months ago
Very good if you like frozen yogurt.

Melanie Disilvestre

18 July 2023
10 months ago
Awesome spot!! They have frozen yogurt acai bowls etc. Joe makes the best chocolate peanut butter smoothie! It's very filling I get it for lunch

Tara Garcia

02 July 2023
a year ago
Very large facility, lots of options, and friendly staff.

holly murtha

22 June 2023
a year ago
Bubble tea took 1/2 hr to get…coffee too 20 min….smoothie too forever….got soft serve from the wall. It was good. Novel idea. However now I have my ice cream an...
Read more

Raúl La Sombra

21 April 2023
a year ago
The peanut butter cup shake might have been the worst tasting thing in the world, maybe ever. Milk must’ve been expired or something. Really bad

Kiersten Connolly

17 April 2023
a year ago
Total ripnoff! We went in there after the movies. I was with my 4 year old and 6 year old. I asked the woman working if the fro yo went by weight nd she barely ...
Read more

Rey Davila

12 April 2023
a year ago
A little pricey, but I guess that's in line for Suffolk County, especially the Port Jeff area.

Robert Rainer

06 January 2023
a year ago
Nice variety of flavors and toppings

Jessica Klein (Jessie)

11 December 2022
a year ago

Cloudz

19 November 2022
2 years ago
Emily, Andrew, and Angelina were angels tonight at this place they helped me and my children get the best top quality ice cream as well as provide amazing custo...
Read more

Noah Metzler

24 October 2022
2 years ago
This place used to be a 5 star establishment but they got rid of some of there ice cream toppings and everything else is a bit pricey so they sadly dropped to a...
Read more

Candice Rodriguez

16 October 2022
2 years ago
Always frustrated with being understaffed and offering products then not having them. Advertise diary free ice cream and the last 3 times they didn't have it. N...
Read more

My Circle

14 October 2022
2 years ago
Tasty but when I arrived 2 hours after opening, half the frozen yogurt machines were not turned on and 1/3 of the toppings were out. Seemed pretty unorganized. ...
Read more

Chris M

04 August 2022
2 years ago
Great local business with many delicious options! The staff is very friendly and the place is very clean! Love coming here.

Barbara Spendstoomuchmoney

14 July 2022
2 years ago

Alexis Delaney

13 July 2022
2 years ago

JINGDA FENG

13 July 2022
2 years ago

Chuckie Barrett

29 June 2022
2 years ago
Great luv this place Great staff best strawberry shake on long island 🏝 😋

Patricia Livolsi

29 June 2022
2 years ago
If there were 0 stars that’s what it deserves. I went for a yogurt and waited at least 15 minutes with yogurt in hand. One person was in store waiting for her o...
Read more

P.J. Jaymes

31 May 2022
2 years ago

mariah

27 May 2022
2 years ago

Jake C

22 May 2022
2 years ago

Casper Frankenstein

12 May 2022
2 years ago
Asked for a nutrition guide with items calories and ingredients, the young blonde girl rudely said no and walked away from me… people need to know macronutrient...
Read more

Samantha Vogel-Hespos

04 April 2022
2 years ago
Ice cream is overpriced. Not many flavors to choose from. Staff is unfriendly and overpriced ice cream.

Codi Ingram

29 March 2022
2 years ago
Always delicious. Employees go the extra mile!

Madison

19 March 2022
2 years ago
I normally order from here after the gym and get a peanut butter protein shake. A guy with long dead blonde hair took over 10 minutes to ring me up because he d...
Read more

Dave Padula Jr

18 March 2022
2 years ago
I ordered a single açaí bowl and dippinndots, 40 minutes later the kid brings out açaí bowls for every other customer but me and I’m sitting here waiting this i...
Read more

Michael Salvia

13 February 2022
2 years ago
If you can afford highway robbery then I highly recommend this. Unless you're diabetic like me. They don't have sugar free frozen yogurt.

nikojames49

08 February 2022
2 years ago

Glen Amato

28 November 2021
2 years ago
Ordered a Oreo cookies and cream cake Friday night pay for it over the phone. They said it would be ready Saturday at noon went there Saturday about 1:00 p.m. t...
Read more

Nicole Sarno

11 November 2021
3 years ago

Ryan M

28 September 2021
3 years ago
Great frozen yogurt lots of toppings.

Dotty Cool

16 September 2021
3 years ago
This place is horrible! I waited 35 minutes for a shake and nobody was there! And this happend multiple times! No other customers were there and By the time my ...
Read more

Brian Sondi

12 September 2021
3 years ago
Purchased chocolate soft serve ice cream that was bad (sour!!), was told that I cannot receive a refund!

Deborah Palumbo

12 September 2021
3 years ago
Grandkids had fun picking the yogurt and toppings.

Christina Lombardi

10 September 2021
3 years ago
Half of the machines didn’t work, bugs flying around ice cream toppings, clearly unclean establishment. And waited 10 minutes for someone to finally ring us up....
Read more

Willy Pete

07 September 2021
3 years ago
Ordered the small acai bowl, was a bit pricey but it was worth it. On the other hand you can load up on toppings at a fixed price for the frozen yogurt

Roger West

19 August 2021
3 years ago

Marilyn Sullivan

17 August 2021
3 years ago

james Ingram

09 August 2021
3 years ago

Kate Meyer

25 July 2021
3 years ago
Sundaes did an amazing job for my nephews birthday. The staff was awesome! Did a great job with our crazy group. The ice cream was also really delicious… and ha...
Read more

Zemira simmons

20 July 2021
3 years ago
There yogurt was really good and had nice toppings.

Monica zelaya

20 July 2021
3 years ago

Elia Trejo

24 June 2021
3 years ago

AnnMarie Logan

21 June 2021
3 years ago

Chad Beckford

06 June 2021
3 years ago
Great stuff

Harrison Mitchell

28 May 2021
3 years ago
Great

Stephen Powers

22 May 2021
3 years ago

R Krisch

17 May 2021
3 years ago
Worst run establishment. Yogurt machines never work properly. Toppings center always a dirty mess. Given this place so many chances. One would think at the star...
Read more

thomas h

15 March 2021
3 years ago

Keegan Johnson

13 March 2021
3 years ago

Luisa Echeverry

04 March 2021
3 years ago

Shonte Henderson

03 March 2021
3 years ago

Gloria Atwood

13 December 2020
3 years ago
My daughter and I love this place! Yummy and delicious!

Andrea Fowora

23 October 2020
4 years ago
My sisters and I are regulars here. We have tried açaí bowls at a lot of different places but none compare to Sundaes!! The bowls are consistently fresh and del...
Read more

F Marchese

10 September 2020
4 years ago
Nice place to get some dessert. Very clean and the girls work hard.

marek guberski

08 September 2020
4 years ago

Dante Giunta

13 August 2020
4 years ago
Great service. The workers were so friendly. Would definitely recommend to go for a quick stop or for family night

Emily Fein

13 August 2020
4 years ago
Best place to go to in Long Island. The girls working behind the counter were absolutely amazing and so helpful for the questions I asked. 10/10 recommend to go...
Read more

wink wonk

05 May 2020
4 years ago
I was doing doordash and there was this employee that has gave me an attitude. As customers came in the store, she told me that i can wait. I was waiting for ab...
Read more

Eric Feeley

21 March 2020
4 years ago
Great place. Friendly staff and great selections.

Audiomaniac 2310

29 December 2019
4 years ago
Waited 25 minutes for 2 expensive and not very good shakes. My last time here / go anywhere else except this place.

Arlene velez

30 October 2019
5 years ago
Cool

Al Bque

06 October 2019
5 years ago

Tim Sowden

03 October 2019
5 years ago
Has some non-dairy options.👍

Allister McGuire

28 September 2019
5 years ago
Really good frozen yogurt plus the awesome cookie dough bar.

Erin Tighe

03 September 2019
5 years ago

Leadfoot Sam Markson

02 September 2019
5 years ago

spikester7878

12 July 2019
5 years ago

David Rosado

08 July 2019
5 years ago

Josh N

23 June 2019
5 years ago
This was our first time going there and we missed these signs. My girlfriend and I were just trying to go for some light post dinner dessert. We accidentally g...
Read more

Sam Ferraro

16 June 2019
5 years ago
Love this place! Staff is super nice, they work hard and they have fun while doing it!

Joey T

13 June 2019
5 years ago
Absolutely atrocious. We used to go all the time, after tonight's experience my wife and I will no longer be going here. 1/2 of the flavors weren't working, t...
Read more

Andre` Biggs

29 May 2019
5 years ago

Craig Fazio

20 May 2019
5 years ago
We normally like Sundaes for what it is. The kids (4 of them) enjoy serving themselves and creating a masterpiece. My son and I both chose chocolate and they w...
Read more

Tom Abruzzo

18 May 2019
5 years ago

david samson

08 May 2019
5 years ago

Nichole Frank

20 April 2019
5 years ago
I have yet to find a better froyo place on Long Island. Sundaes is the best! Especially that edible cookie dough bar, it's my favorite.

Angie Powell

12 April 2019
5 years ago

Dwagon Slayer 100

06 April 2019
5 years ago

Anne Varca

31 March 2019
5 years ago

Spencer Patterson

13 March 2019
5 years ago

Sarah Frank

01 March 2019
5 years ago

syeda Abbas

18 February 2019
5 years ago

Benjamin Rose

15 January 2019
5 years ago
Amazing froyo. Great flavor selection. Cheesecake flavor was so amazing I'll be back for more

Jonah Yonks

04 January 2019
5 years ago

Derrick Ramdeen

29 December 2018
5 years ago

Lidy Franklin

21 December 2018
5 years ago

Brian Stoma

30 October 2018
6 years ago
Excellent place you have choice to pay by ounce or get the one price cup for a lot of toppings.

Kaitlyn “Kaity” Danielsen

01 October 2018
6 years ago

Doodler5106

20 September 2018
6 years ago

Jack Horne

16 September 2018
6 years ago

Dawn Acocella

30 August 2018
6 years ago
Really good and have alot of options 😋

Henry La Roche

27 August 2018
6 years ago

DarkSidesHero

27 August 2018
6 years ago
Good froyo. Place becomes a bit of a mess during the later hours though.

Corey B

24 August 2018
6 years ago

ATIQ HASSAN

16 August 2018
6 years ago

Tiffany Pliakis

05 August 2018
6 years ago
Staff is excellent, love the selfserve and all the choices, I use to go every day that's how great it was. So many topping pickings also

Candice Rodriguez

31 July 2018
6 years ago

Steve Friello

24 July 2018
6 years ago

KATHRYN SIMMONS

21 July 2018
6 years ago
Gina and her staff did an outstanding job with our sons 9th birthday celebration! They are "incredibly" professional, kind, efficient and friendly! Highly recom...
Read more

Mikayla Riley

21 July 2018
6 years ago
Sooooo many choices of frozen yogurt and ice cream and sooooooo many amazing topping choices but can get a bit pricey

Toni Galati

20 July 2018
6 years ago

Norma Aleman

16 July 2018
6 years ago

B Wynn

05 July 2018
6 years ago

cor maresca

30 June 2018
6 years ago

Michael Derck

25 June 2018
6 years ago

Joe Barone (ItzBarnone)

20 June 2018
6 years ago

Empoleon King

17 June 2018
6 years ago
I got food poisoning

Tom Tommaso

22 May 2018
6 years ago
Pretty good, can get a little pricey. Get the fixed price cup cause the per ounce one can get real expensive real quickly.

Maria Kay

18 May 2018
6 years ago
First time here. Loved it. Recommend the basic $5.00 cup and go crazy.

Maria

17 May 2018
6 years ago
They have regular ice cream or frozen yogurt (multiple flavors too, not just chocolate and vanilla) and a toppings bar that you won't be able to control yoursel...
Read more

Star Treatments

12 May 2018
6 years ago
Meh.... This place has mediocre ice cream for kinda expensive prices and lots of crappy toppings. I got an ice cream cone and my son got a cup. The cone was sta...
Read more

Dina Tennekoon

08 May 2018
6 years ago

Slay S

29 April 2018
6 years ago
Cool spot. Outdoor seating.